Wayne Bowen is a friend of mine in Missouri and sends along this guest post with a look at the Missouri primary today. Bowen is the chair of the history department at Southeast Missouri State University.
Missouri has an intriguing primary today. In most cases, the outcome is a foregone conclusion, but the results will still be interesting. On the Democratic side, Missouri Secretary of State Robin Carnahan faces token opposition in her run for the US Senate. The Carnahan name is legendary in Missouri politics; her brother is a Congressman, her father was governor and her mother was a US Senator. The GOP race, as with most contests in the state this time, has a bit more drama. The front-runner among nine candidates for the Republican US Senate nomination is 7th District Congressman Roy Blunt. A former House Minority Whip, Blunt is also the father of former Missouri Governor Matt Blunt. Among the minor GOP candidates, State Senator Chuck Purgason has made the most impact with a small but vocal following among a minority of Tea Party folks. Purgason is campaigning against Blunt as an outsider, using Blunt support for TARP and some earmarks. Arkansas has a connection to this race, as Blunt has been endorsed by Mike Huckabee. While in most years this would be an obvious move, one of the HuckPac Missouri organizers has blasted Huckabee and tried to organize a mini-revolt (emphasis on mini), claiming that Purgason is the real conservative in the race. There is pushback, however, since Blunt is the overwhelming favorite to win, is a proven fundraiser, and is a known and respected figure within the GOP. He has a ACU lifetime of 93%, so it is not as if he is a RINO, either. My prediction would be that Congressman Blunt will take 75% or more in the primary, even with the other candidates in the race. Purgason for sure will come in 2nd – how can he not with ‘Joe the Plumber’ on board? – but probably in the 15% range. Blunt certainly isn’t concerned about his primary opponents, as all of his fire is directed against Robin Carnahan. Congressman Blunt is a good speaker, can inspire the party faithful while also appealing to the center, and is so far slightly ahead of Carnahan in most of the polls. Missouri is so evenly matched – St. Louis and Kansas City vs. the rest of the state – that most of the high profile races end of within a few point margin. I suspect that in the general Blunt will win with something in the 55% range – a little higher than a typical victory here, but Obama is a lot more unpopular than in 2008, when McCain/Palin narrowly carried Missouri. Blunt is well-organized, has personally campaigned in every one of our 114 counties (plus the independent city of St. Louis), and is a fundraising machine. I’ve seen a few signs and flyers for Purgason, but his campaign doesn’t have a very professional image, and he has nowhere near the momentum or visibility of, for example, insurgent campaigns even at the level of Jim Holt — who, of course, was soundly trounced by a candidate with a voting record and demographic base nearly identical to Blunt’s.
Missouri will also vote on Proposition C, an initiative against the Obama health care law. Prop C, sponsored by the Republican state legislature, declares null and void the mandate to buy health insurance, and also eases some of the pending rules on insurance companies. The initiative seems likely to pass, as it is being promoted by the Republican Party and its candidates, and turnout should be much higher in the Republican primary. There has only been token opposition, other than some modest efforts by the Missouri Hospital Association, since the measure will have no force of law. As a statement of public opinion, however, Proposition C will provide some momentum for those calling for the repeal and replacement of the Democratic Party’s health care legislation. It is also proving helpful in Get Out The Vote efforts. With 61% of Missourians disapproving of Obama’s health care law, according to late July poll by the St. Louis Post Dispatch and KMOV poll, Prop C seems likely to pass handily.
The state also has primary contests for congressional, legislative and local races. In the 7th District GOP Primary to choose a replacement for Roy Blunt, Bill Long, an auctioneer and local celebrity, appears to have the slight edge in fundraising, endorsements (including Mike Huckabee), and campaign organization for this southwestern Missouri district. State Senators Jack Goodman and Gary Nodler, along with Iraq war veteran Jeff Wisdom, local prosecutor Darrell Moore, and a couple of minor candidates, are also campaigning hard. As with Arkansas’ 3rd District, winning the GOP primary here is, as they say, “tantamount to election.”
In the 8th Congressional District, Republican incumbent Jo Ann Emerson faces a primary opponent also endorsed by some Tea Party organizations. Bob Parker, a rancher and small businessman, is campaigning against Emerson in a manner similar to that of Chuck Purgason, and likely to the same effect. Emerson is very popular in the district, and has received over 85% in the Republican primaries where she has faced opposition. In the general election, Emerson will face Iraq war veteran Tommy Sowers, who has almost matched Emerson in fundraising – thanks to support from retired general Wesley Clark, among others. Sowers is an attractive candidates, but has run a lackluster campaign, with much of his campaign expenditures going toward staff. He has also attracted negative attention for his support from East and West Coast liberal groups, such as Moveon.org and Howard Dean, hardly a fit for this most rural and conservative district.
Republican votes will outnumber Democratic votes in the primary by a significant margin – perhaps 60-40. While the general election will likely be closer, momentum and interest does seem to be on the side of the GOP in Missouri this year, the most bellwether of the bellwether states. Barring dramatic improvements in President Obama’s popularity here – he’s at 34% according to the most recent poll- today’s primary could signal a disastrous November for the Democratic Party in Missouri.